I Audited the AI Benchmark Everyone Uses to Measure Progress. Nearly Half Its Questions Are Broken.
Epoch AI reviewed 15 major AI benchmarks and flagged 9 as flawed, including Humanity's Last Exam, where a hand-audited sample of 48 questions found 22 defective. I took their findings and ran them: filtering the broken items out of a live leaderboard, and the scores barely move. Both findings are true and they are not in tension.






